Plastic bag tax being proposed
Victoria Wallack
The chairman of the Legislature's Natural Resources Committee is on a
mission to eliminate 90 percent of those ubiquitous plastic grocery bags
Mainers now use by the millions each year and believes it will take a
per-bag fee to make it happen.
Rep. Ted Koffman, D-Bar Harbor, has a bill he's trying to get in for
next year that will be reviewed by the Legislative Council on Thursday.
Koffman's is one of 134 bills legislators have asked the council to
reconsider after it initially rejected all but 148 out of 566
submitted.
"Whether or not the bill is approved, we're going to keep working,"
Koffman said, to come up with a solution that involves both a carrot and
stick to change behavior.
Koffman's proposal would include a 20-cent fee on plastic bags, which
he said is a negotiable "starting point."
He said some of the money raised would go to educate the public about
the need to reduce the number of plastic bags that fill up landfills or
end up floating in waterways or clogging drains. The fee also could help
subsidize reusable shopping bags for store customers or pay for prizes in
a lottery that could only be entered by those using specially marked
reusable bags.
"If you put a fee on it you're sending a message that might influence
customer choice," he said. "On the other hand, if there's a lottery
attached to it," that incentive could draw more people in "for the chance
to nail the thousand dollars worth of fruits or vegetables or cash."
Koffman said he is in discussions with Hannaford Supermarkets and the
Maine Grocers Association. He said any bill he proposes has to be the
result of a cooperative effort among groceries and the Legislature or he
won't pursue it. And, he said, the bill would not target small stores.
"I wouldn't want to take action that makes it hard on smaller
businesses," he said.
Amie Joseph, director of the Maine Grocers Association, said Koffman
has been very open about his plans and there are ongoing discussions about
what should happen next.
She said her group would like to spend the next year educating the
public and stores about the need to recycle plastic bags, use only the
amount needed and look at alternatives.
"We're interested in what's going on all over the country and pretty
much all over the world," she said. "We are hoping we can use this year to
just start educating our stores and educating our customers."
"Our main concern is jumping into legislation without really figuring
out what the problem is and what the goal is and levying a fee on
consumers without letting consumers know what choices they already have,"
she said.
Maine, for example, already requires stores to provide a place to
recycle plastic bags, yet not all consumers know that.
"Whether (his bill) gets in or not, we're going to continue to go
forward and be as proactive as possible. We just want to get out ahead of
the curve," Joseph said.
San Francisco became the first U.S. city to outlaw plastic bags al-
together earlier this year in a phased-in program that affects large
supermarkets and pharmacy chains. Stores will have the option of using
compostable bags made of corn starch or bags made of recyclable paper.
Koffman said his proposal is modeled after one in Ireland, which
imposed a 15-cent tax on plastic bags in 2002 that resulted in a 90
percent reduction in their use. That fee was just raised to 22 cents.
The idea of a tax on plastic bags also has captured the attention of
progressive groups including the Center for Policy Alternatives in
Washington, D.C., which tries to educate and cajole legislators to adopt
progressive legislation.
According to its Web site, 12 million barrels of oil are needed to
produce the 100 billion plastic bags Americans consume each year. And
while plastic bags can be recycled, only about five percent are.
Koffman said that because of the rising price of oil, groceries would
like to get out of the plastic bag business. He referred to a program at
Hannaford where a credit is given to customers, who bring their own
bag.
"A number of retailers would prefer not to have to buy all this plastic
bag stuff," he said. "It's not like I'm ramming something down an
unwilling throat."
|